When the Regulated Wagering Market Becomes Unviable, Everyone Loses

Australian racing depends on wagering revenue, but the businesses generating that revenue must also be able to make a living. When taking a reasonable bet becomes commercially unviable, the consequences reach beyond the bookmaker. Punters lose choice, competition weakens and racing risks eroding the very market it relies on.

That raises a question the industry can no longer afford to avoid: how much can the licensed wagering market carry before the cost of participation starts to undermine its future?

The regulated wagering industry is now being squeezed from almost every direction. Operators face point-of-consumption taxes, race-field and sporting product fees, GST, licensing costs, data costs, payment processing expenses and an expanding range of responsible wagering, anti-money laundering and regulatory compliance obligations.

These costs are imposed by different governments, regulators, racing bodies and sporting organisations. Each may have a legitimate purpose when considered separately, but there is rarely enough consideration of their cumulative effect.

The result is a regulated market in which taking a bet, and even winning from that bet, does not necessarily mean the bookmaker has made a profit.

A customer loss is not a bookmaker’s profit

When a customer loses money with a licensed wagering operator, the bookmaker does not simply retain that entire amount. Before the ordinary costs of running the business are considered, portions of that revenue are already committed to product fees, point-of-consumption tax and GST. Operators must then fund staff, technology, data, payments, fraud prevention, customer verification, financial guarantees and an increasingly sophisticated compliance framework.

For many operators, a customer generating a gross win margin of between zero and ten per cent can now be commercially unviable.

In plain terms, a punter can lose money to a bookmaker while the bookmaker still loses money servicing that customer. This is a serious warning sign. A regulated wagering market should not require customers to lose at increasingly high rates before it becomes commercially viable for an operator to accept their business. When lower-margin customers become unviable, the predictable response is more defensive pricing, reduced markets, lower limits, greater scrutiny of accounts and less willingness to compete for informed customers.

Those outcomes are frustrating for punters, but they are not occurring in a vacuum. They are being shaped by an operating model in which an increasing share of wagering revenue is removed before the bookmaker has covered the basic cost of offering the service.

Smaller and independent wagering service providers experience this pressure most immediately because they do not have the scale, customer volume or internal infrastructure available to major corporate operators.

However, this is not only a small-bookmaker issue. Smaller operators are the first indication that the broader market is becoming unsustainable. If the cost of participation makes them unviable, market concentration increases and the regulated industry becomes increasingly dependent on a small number of very large businesses. This, in-turn, affects consumer choice, competitive pricing and the resilience of the wagering market. It also narrows the revenue base on which racing and sport rely.

Advocating for smaller bookmakers is therefore not about seeking special treatment for a particular group of businesses. It is about recognising what their viability tells us about the health of the regulated market as a whole.

The wrong question is being asked

The correct question for governments, racing bodies and sporting organisations is not how much more can be charged to wagering operators - it is what fee structure will maximise sustainable revenue from a competitive, regulated wagering market.

A higher fee may generate more revenue from each individual bet while simultaneously reducing the number of operators, markets and competitive prices available. If a fee causes bookmakers to withdraw from particular products, makes lower-margin customers unviable or pushes smaller operators out of the industry, the result may be a larger percentage being collected from an increasingly smaller market.

Sustainable revenue depends on more than the headline rate. It depends on participation, turnover, product appeal, competition and the ability of licensed operators to provide customers with a viable alternative to the illegal market.

Racing and sporting bodies are entitled to receive a fair return from wagering conducted on their products, however the question is whether current structures are maximising the long-term value of those products or prioritising immediate extraction without adequately considering the consequences.

A healthy wagering industry should not be measured solely by the rate charged. It should be measured by the total sustainable revenue it produces, the competition it supports and the number of customers it keeps within the regulated system.

We are strengthening the illegal offshore market

This cumulative burden of these costs does not eliminate customer demand - it changes where that demand is directed.

Illegal offshore online casinos can offer products that licensed Australian wagering operators are prohibited from providing. They can also operate without paying Australian wagering taxes, Australian racing and sporting product fees or the full cost of complying with the Australian regulatory framework. They are not carrying the same financial obligations, responsible wagering requirements, customer-verification standards or consumer protections imposed on licensed Australian operators (in some cases they are actively targeting problem gamblers in Australia who have nationally self-excluded).

This results in a fundamentally distorted market. The regulated industry is being required to offer a more restricted product at a materially higher cost, while illegal operators use those differences to attract Australian customers willing to use a VPN.

When licensed bookmakers respond to rising costs with shorter prices, reduced offers or tighter customer controls, illegal offshore casinos become more appealing to punters. They can offer a broader range of products and promotions precisely because they are ignoring the laws and costs that apply to legitimate operators.

This is not simply lost revenue for bookmakers, it also means lost wagering taxes for governments, lost product fees for racing and sport, less effective consumer protection and more Australian customers gambling with businesses beyond the practical reach of Australian regulators.

Bookmakers must also come to the table

This means offering fair prices, accepting reasonable bets, managing risk and treating genuine customers consistently. It means competing through product, service and expertise rather than relying predominantly on promotions, restrictions or scale.

Bookmaking necessarily involves risk. Operators cannot ask governments and racing bodies to address the structural pressures on the industry without also examining whether their own practices are delivering a fair and competitive product to customers.

At the same time, bookmakers cannot reasonably be expected to accept greater risk when the cost structure makes an ordinary lower-margin customer commercially unviable - it must work both ways. If the financial burden on regulated operators is reduced, bookmakers must use that opportunity to compete more genuinely. The benefit should be visible to punters through better pricing, reasonable limits, improved service and a greater willingness to take a bet.

The objective is not cheaper operating conditions for bookmakers in isolation. It is a stronger regulated market that produces better outcomes for customers and more sustainable revenue for racing, sport and government.

Effective regulation must remain central

Commercial sustainability is not an argument for weakening responsible wagering, integrity or anti-money laundering standards; it is an argument for ensuring that regulatory obligations are effective, proportionate and coordinated.

Good regulation should be assessed by the harm it prevents and the outcomes it produces, rather than simply by the volume of compliance activity it generates. When obligations overlap or conflict between jurisdictions, operators are required to direct resources towards duplication instead of improved customer protection.

The regulated industry must remain commercially capable of competing with illegal alternatives. Otherwise, increasingly strict rules may protect customers who remain within the Australian system while unintentionally encouraging others to leave it altogether. Responsible wagering, consumer protection and commercial viability should not be treated as competing objectives. All three are necessary for a sustainable regulated market.

Genuine punters must remain part of the discussion

Bookmakers now manage a complicated combination of obligations involving customer identification, responsible wagering, minimum bet rules, taxation, product fees and account activity.

Account misuse, proxy betting and attempts to circumvent wagering rules are legitimate concerns. However, they are part of a broader industry environment and should not become the default explanation for every difficult or successful customer - the industry needs better and more consistent ways to distinguish genuine punters from activity intended to circumvent the rules.

Genuine customers should not be unfairly restricted because bookmakers and regulators are attempting to manage weaknesses or inconsistencies in the broader framework. If the industry wants punters to remain with regulated Australian operators, it must ensure that the regulated product remains fair, competitive and worthwhile to use.

Previous
Previous

Wentworth Park farewells 94 years of greyhound racing

Next
Next

A New Chapter for the NSW Bookmakers’ Cooperative