A New Chapter for the NSW Bookmakers’ Cooperative

By Sophia Alati, Chief Executive Officer

Taking over as Chief Executive Officer of the NSW Bookmakers’ Co-operative following the retirement of Les Mellowship is both a privilege and a significant responsibility.

Les has made an enormous contribution to the Co-operative and its members. I am fortunate to be stepping into an organisation with strong foundations, an experienced Board and a membership that understands the importance of working collectively.

My immediate priority is to preserve what the Co-operative has always done well while ensuring that it continues to evolve alongside the industry it represents.

I have worked across racing and wagering for more than a decade, with experience spanning marketing, regulatory compliance, industry consulting and advocacy. That experience has given me an appreciation of both the commercial realities of operating a wagering business and the increasingly complicated regulatory environment surrounding it.

The wagering industry is currently navigating a period of considerable change. The pressures facing bookmakers cannot be attributed to any single group, policy or development. They are the cumulative result of increasing product fees and wagering taxes, overlapping state and federal regulation, growing compliance costs, rapid technological change, market consolidation and changing customer behaviour.

There are also emerging challenges involving account misuse, proxy betting, minimum bet obligations and the practical application of promotional and jurisdictional restrictions. These matters need to be addressed, but they form only one part of a much broader industry environment requiring thoughtful and coordinated reform.

Smaller and independent wagering operators often experience these pressures most acutely. They do not necessarily have the scale, resources or internal infrastructure available to large corporate operators, yet they are frequently required to meet the same regulatory and technological obligations.

The cumulative effect can materially influence which markets an operator can offer, the prices they can provide and whether it remains commercially viable for them to participate at all.

This does not only affect bookmakers. It ultimately affects competition, consumer choice and the quality of the wagering market available to punters.

However, advocacy on behalf of bookmakers cannot be one-sided. Bookmakers must also be prepared to come to the table.

If governments, regulators, racing bodies and sporting organisations are able to ease disproportionate taxation, product-fee and compliance burdens, there must be something meaningful delivered in return.

Reduced costs should not simply be absorbed into operator margins. They should create the conditions for genuine and competitive bookmaking to return.

That means bookmakers being prepared to frame competitive markets, offer fair prices, accept reasonable bets, manage risk and treat genuine customers consistently. It also means competing through service, product and expertise rather than relying solely on promotions or customer restrictions.

Bookmaking necessarily involves risk. A sustainable wagering sector cannot be built around operators asking for protection from every commercial pressure while offering little additional value to customers or the industries whose products they sell.

At the same time, bookmakers cannot provide genuine competition if their cost base forces them to defend every dollar before a bet has even been taken. The objective must be to create an environment in which operators have both the capacity and the expectation to bookmake properly.

The bargain must work both ways. If the industry provides bookmakers with greater commercial breathing room, bookmakers must use it to strengthen competition and deliver a better wagering market for punters.

A diverse wagering sector is important. Competition should not simply mean having multiple brands in the market if those brands are increasingly concentrated within a small number of large corporate groups. Genuine competition requires operators of different sizes and business models to have a reasonable opportunity to participate.

One of my central priorities will be advocating for regulation that achieves genuine harm-minimisation outcomes while remaining practical, consistent and commercially sustainable.

Responsible wagering must remain at the centre of the industry. However, good regulation should be assessed by the harm it prevents and the outcomes it produces, rather than simply by the amount of compliance activity it generates.

When requirements overlap, conflict between jurisdictions or impose disproportionate costs without a clear benefit, they can unintentionally strengthen the position of the largest operators while making it more difficult for smaller businesses to compete.

A strong wagering industry needs effective consumer protections, but it also needs diversity, competition and regulation that reflects how wagering operates in practice.

Genuine punters must also remain part of this conversation.

Bookmakers now manage an increasingly complicated combination of obligations relating to customer identification, responsible wagering, minimum bet limits, taxation, product fees and account activity. Questions about who is controlling or benefiting from an account can create legitimate compliance concerns, but they can also result in genuine customers being subjected to additional scrutiny or restrictions.

The industry needs better and more consistent systems for distinguishing genuine customers from activity intended to circumvent wagering rules. Genuine punters should not be unfairly disadvantaged because bookmakers and regulators are attempting to manage weaknesses or inconsistencies in the broader framework.

Resolving these issues will require cooperation between bookmakers, regulators, racing bodies, sporting organisations and wagering customers. Addressing each problem in isolation risks treating the symptoms without examining the circumstances that created them.

Alongside my role with the Co-operative, I will continue working with Australian Bookmakers Association Chairman Chris Lester to advocate nationally for smaller and independent wagering service providers.

Our work will include engagement with governments, regulators, racing authorities and sporting bodies on wagering regulation, race-field and product fees, taxation, illegal offshore operators, consumer protection, access to industry data and the long-term sustainability of independent bookmaking.

Australian wagering is governed through a combination of federal laws, state and territory licensing regimes, racing-industry rules and individual product-fee arrangements. Each requirement may have a legitimate purpose when viewed independently, but their combined effect can create duplication, inconsistency and unintended consequences.

The industry needs a more coordinated approach and a greater understanding of the cumulative effect these decisions have on operators, competition and consumers.

The Co-operative itself represents a diverse membership comprising traditional on-course bookmakers, online wagering service providers and businesses operating across both environments.

Although these members may operate differently, both groups require meaningful representation.

For online operators, the focus must include commercially sustainable product fees, practical regulation, fair access to industry data and the preservation of genuine competition.

For on-course bookmakers, we must protect and promote the betting ring as an important part of the history, atmosphere and identity of Australian racing.

We cannot assume that betting rings will survive simply because they have always existed. They need to remain visible, accessible and engaging for a new generation of racegoers.

There is something fundamentally different about standing in a betting ring, comparing prices, speaking directly with a bookmaker and watching the market move. That experience remains valuable, but the industry must do a better job of introducing it to people whose first instinct is to reach for an app.

The future of bookmaking will not be purely online or purely on-course. It will involve different operating models serving different customers. The role of the Co-operative is to ensure those models have the opportunity to remain viable and that the people operating them have a meaningful voice in the decisions affecting their businesses.

A diverse and competitive bookmaking sector benefits racing, supports consumer choice and gives genuine punters access to a broader range of operators, products and prices.

Under my leadership, the Co-operative will continue to work constructively with industry stakeholders while being prepared to challenge decisions that create unnecessary costs, reduce competition or fail to deliver their intended regulatory outcome.

My objective is to ensure the Co-operative remains a strong, modern and credible representative body, while helping to preserve bookmaking as a competitive, responsible and important part of Australian racing.

Previous
Previous

When the Regulated Wagering Market Becomes Unviable, Everyone Loses