Two men who have watched their own horses run in the Melbourne Cup made the news this week. Tony Santic wanted three trophies back. Stuart Ramsey wanted the chance to bring his horse home.
Makybe Diva’s three Melbourne Cup trophies were stolen from their display at Flemington on Monday. Two days later, the Melbourne Racing Club confirmed that Red Fury’s 1948 Caulfield Cup had been stolen from Caulfield Racecourse.
Victoria Police allege two men smashed the Flemington display cabinet at about 6.30am on Monday and took Makybe Diva’s three Cups, valued at about $3 million together. Latest news reports allege that a fourth Melbourne Cup from an unidentified year was also taken days prior to the Makybe Diva theft.
A fortnight earlier, about 30 people had gone to Flemington with Ramsey to watch So You Are, the gelding his family bred, run eighth in the Cup. “He brought our family together,” Ramsey told Australian Associated Press.
Thirteen days after the Cup, So You Are developed severe colic. Vets at REC Equine Specialists tried to save him and ultimately had to euthanise him. Later that day, footage from Lucas Heights showed him lying in a skip.
Wagering and racing are intrinsically linked. For many of us, the love of the horses came before the job in wagering. Others know what it is to stand at the rail and watch a horse they own go round.
An owner should be able to count on a conversation with the vet about what happens next. Stuart Ramsey told 2GB he was never offered the chance to bring So You Are home.
Before the gelding was collected, did anyone explain the available options to the family or the person authorised to speak for them? What instructions did the clinic receive and record? If nobody asked, how did burial at Lucas Heights become the plan?
REC says it chose the contractor and expected the gelding to be buried promptly at a licensed landfill.
Cleanaway says the vehicle that delivered him could not safely access the landfill’s tipping face (the area where waste is unloaded), so staff transferred him to a skip under the site’s usual procedures.
Racing NSW has explained that the drugs used in euthanasia are one reason a licensed landfill is preferred. Had the burial gone ahead exactly as planned and no footage ever emerged, would we have been satisfied that a tip was a fitting place to farewell him?
If you backed So You Are on Cup Day, you had every reason to expect he’d be treated with care long after the bets were settled. As bookmakers, we can understand why seeing that footage might make you think twice about having a bet next Saturday.
Once a punter is asking whether they feel comfortable backing a horse at all, the price on the board is beside the point.
Racing NSW’s 2026 annual report puts the annual return from race field fees at about $154 million. That income supports race clubs and prizemoney. Sponsorship brings money directly into clubs too, as this week’s naming rights deal between TAB and the Gold Coast Turf Club shows.
If landfill burial is routine, Racing NSW should commission and publish an independent study into how often it happens, what owners are told and what safe alternatives are available. An owner saying goodbye to a maiden has as much right to those answers as the Ramseys.
Our industry can only survive if we respect the horses who make it possible. We owed So You Are that respect when he walked into the mounting yard at Flemington. We owed it to him just as much when he left the hospital.